Blame
|
1 | --- |
||||||
| 2 | category: reference |
|||||||
| 3 | tags: [meta, phase-1, gate] |
|||||||
| 4 | last_updated: 2026-03-13 |
|||||||
| 5 | confidence: high |
|||||||
| 6 | --- |
|||||||
| 7 | ||||||||
| 8 | # Phase 1 Gate Results |
|||||||
| 9 | ||||||||
| 10 | Validation performed 2026-03-13. Results for each exit criterion from [[Design/Phase_Gates]]. |
|||||||
| 11 | ||||||||
| 12 | ## Summary |
|||||||
| 13 | ||||||||
|
14 | **7/7 criteria PASS. Gate cleared 2026-03-13.** |
||||||
|
15 | |||||||
| 16 | ## Results |
|||||||
| 17 | ||||||||
| 18 | | Criterion | Result | Notes | |
|||||||
| 19 | |-----------|--------|-------| |
|||||||
| 20 | | Web UI works | **PASS** | Human confirmed: pages load, edit, save at dev.wikibot.io | |
|||||||
|
21 | | REST API works | **PASS** | All CRUD, search, semantic search, history, links endpoints work. | |
||||||
|
22 | | MCP works (all 12 tools) | **PASS** | P1-9 fixed OAuth routing. Human confirmed Claude.ai connects and tools work. | |
||||||
|
23 | | Semantic search works | **PASS** | 5/5 queries returned relevant results. On-topic distances 0.46–0.79, off-topic 0.89+ (correctly low confidence). Index has ~233 chunks across ~30 pages. | |
||||||
| 24 | | Git authorship | **PASS** | API commits show "Claude (MCP)" as expected. Historical "Claude (Dev)" from earlier config. One "Otterwiki Robot" initial commit. No anomalies. | |
|||||||
| 25 | | Routing + TLS | **PASS** (6/6) | TLSv1.3, Amazon RSA 2048, cert expires 2026-09-26. Custom domain resolves. HTTPS-only (no port 80 — acceptable). Non-ASCII URLs work. | |
|||||||
| 26 | | Architecture decision | **PASS** | Documented: separate Lambdas for Otterwiki (VPC+EFS) and MCP (stateless, no VPC). Rationale in mcp_server.py docstring. | |
|||||||
| 27 | ||||||||
| 28 | ## Performance |
|||||||
| 29 | ||||||||
| 30 | | Endpoint | Cold | Warm | Assessment | |
|||||||
| 31 | |----------|------|------|------------| |
|||||||
| 32 | | Wiki page (`/Home`) | 1.0s | 0.5s | Acceptable | |
|||||||
| 33 | | API health | 0.25s | 0.25s | Fast | |
|||||||
| 34 | | Authenticated API endpoints | — | — | Not timed (auth header issue in test agent) but functional tests passed in < 1s | |
|||||||
| 35 | ||||||||
| 36 | ## Issues Found |
|||||||
| 37 | ||||||||
|
38 | ### Corrected: `/pages/{path}/links` was not a bug |
||||||
|
39 | |||||||
|
40 | The gate test agent used `GET /api/v1/pages/Home/links` which is the wrong URL. The links endpoint is at `GET /api/v1/links/Home` (a separate route, not a sub-resource of `/pages`). All 12/12 REST API endpoints work correctly. |
||||||
|
41 | |||||||
| 42 | ### Fixed: P1-9 MCP OAuth Routing |
|||||||
| 43 | ||||||||
| 44 | OAuth discovery endpoints were routed to Otterwiki instead of MCP Lambda. Fixed by adding `ANY /.well-known/{proxy+}` API Gateway route and correcting `MCP_BASE_URL`. See [[Tasks/P1-9_MCP_OAuth_Routing]]. |
|||||||
| 45 | ||||||||
| 46 | ### Note: API auth header |
|||||||
| 47 | ||||||||
| 48 | The REST API uses `Authorization: Bearer <token>`, not `X-API-Key`. Some test agents initially used the wrong header. Not a bug — just a documentation clarification. |
|||||||
| 49 | ||||||||
| 50 | ## Go/No-Go |
|||||||
| 51 | ||||||||
|
52 | **GO.** All 7 criteria pass. Phase 1 gate cleared 2026-03-13. Ready to proceed to Phase 2. |
||||||
|
53 | |||||||
| 54 | ## Post-Gate: E2E Test Coverage |
|||||||
| 55 | ||||||||
| 56 | After gate validation, verification found that `tests/test_e2e.py` lacked cross-write-path tests (API→MCP and MCP→API roundtrips). Two tests added (`77cf001`): |
|||||||
| 57 | - `test_api_create_mcp_read` — create via API, read via MCP |
|||||||
| 58 | - `test_mcp_write_api_read` — write via MCP, read via API |
|||||||
| 59 | ||||||||
| 60 | All 17 E2E tests now pass against live dev.wikibot.io (47.69s). |
|||||||